Frank Walker Law
  • Home
  • Attorney Profile
  • Criminal Defense
  • Personal Injury
  • Testimonials
  • Employment Opportunities
  • Contact Us
  • Call Today

    Call Today

  • Email Us

  • Our Map

  • Menu

    Home
    Attorney Profile
    Criminal Defense
    Personal Injury
    Pittsburgh Criminal Defense Blog
    Case Results
    Excessive Force
    Have You Been Arrested?
    Legal Tips
    Media Center
    Testimonials
    Video Center
    Free Legal Evaluation
    Employment Opportunities
    Contact Us
    Site Map
Call To Schedule An Appointment 412.212.3878 Phones Answered 24/7 West Virginia Criminal Defense Attorney
  • Best Law Firms in Americal
  • National Trial Lawyers: Top 40 Under 40
  • National Trial Lawyers: Top 100 Trial Lawyers
  • American Association of Attorneys: Premier DUI
  • National Black Lawyers: Top 100
  • National Academy of Criminal Defense Attorneys
  • Global Law Experts
  • Rue Ratings: Best Attorneys of America
  • DUI Defense Lawyers Association
  • American Institue of Criminal Law Attorneys: 10 Best 2015 Client Satisfaction
  • National College for DUI Defense
Pittsburgh Criminal Defense Blog 2014 June Miranda Warnings - How Do they Really Work?
Previous Post  |  Next Post

Miranda Warnings - How Do they Really Work?

Posted By Frank Walker Law || 19-Jun-2014

We have all seen the shows, right? We all know the Miranda Rights as first recognized in the United States Supreme Court case of Miranda v. Arizona, 384 U.S. 436 (1966)? No? Ok, here are the warnings, word for word:

You have the right to remain silent. Anything you say can and will be used against you in a Court of Law. You have the right to an Attorney. If you cannot afford an attorney, one will be appointed to you.

Do you understand these rights as I have read them to you? With these rights in mind, do you wish to speak to me?

That is it, four short sentences followed by a query of whether the suspect understands the rights as read and if they wish to give a statement. Nevertheless, how and if the warnings apply to an arrest situation in Pennsylvania has been the source of much confusion.

How do the Miranda Rights Apply in Pennsylvania

An officer, agent or investigating officer is only required to read the Miranda warnings once the suspect is in custody. Once the suspect is in custody, the warnings must be given to advise the suspect that any comments they utter during that time could be used against them in Court.

How does this apply? Here is a factual situation: Cops conduct a traffic stop of a suspect in a car. Cops eventually arrest the person for possession with the intent to deliver drugs, suspect is handcuffed and placed beside the police car. While one officer searches the suspect's car, another officer starts to question the suspect: "Where did you get the drugs? Where were you going? Do you have a gun?"

The suspect responds and gives answers that incriminate himself. Officer takes the suspect to the police station for processing. Suspect is arraigned and bond is set. The suspect makes bond and later hires a criminal defense attorney. The Attorney cross examines the arresting officers at the Preliminary Hearing or other pre-trial hearing. The officers admit that they failed to read the suspect the Miranda Warnings and that their questions posed to the suspect where geared to garner a response from the suspect.

In Pennsylvania, the Defense Attorney can later move to suppress or keep out the suspect's statements from trial because the suspect was not advised of his Miranda Warnings prior to offering the statements: The suspect was in custody, interrogated and gave incriminating statements in response to police questioning.

In short, Miranda warnings are given to protect suspects against self-incrimination while in custody and advise the suspect of the opportunity to speak with competent legal Counsel to represent their interests, regardless of ability to pay for the Counsel. The rationale is that incriminating statements must be voluntary and statements given while in custody, in response to police questioning, are presumed involuntary due to the totality of circumstances being inherently coercive.

However, for yourMiranda Rights to apply, you must be in custody or reasonably believe that you are not free to leave and your statements must be given in response to police questioning. In some instances, Courts will find that statements offered during custodial interrogation are presumptively involuntary unless the suspect first receives Miranda Warnings. See e.g. Commonwealth v. DiStefano, 782 A.2d 574, 579 (Pa. Super. 2001), appeal denied, 806 A.2d 858 (Pa. 2002).

When Miranda Rights do not Apply

Officers are not required to give Miranda Warnings if they are questioning or investigating an incident and the suspect blurts out incriminating statements while in police presence but not police custody.

For example, you are approached by police officers while walking down the street and the officer asks "Where are you going? Where have you been? What are you doing? Where you driving Drunk Last Night? Did you steal candy bars from the local grocery store?" You have no obligation to respond or answer any questions, you are not in custody and you should simply remain silent and walk away. If you give any incriminating statements, those statements can be used against you since you were not under arrest, not in custody and the Courts will conclude that you voluntarily offered such statements.

If officers come to your house, knock on the door and ask questions about your involvement in a homicide, robbery, fake id ring or allegations about being publically intoxicated the night before, you have no obligation to respond or answer any questions. You should simply and politely ask the officers to leave, decline to answer any questions and remain silent.

Again, if you give any incriminating statements, those statements can be used against you since you were not under arrest, not in custody and the Courts will find that you voluntarily offered such statements.

Be on the safe side: Just remain silent

Regardless if you are in custody or in police presence, your best course of action is to simply remain silent and immediately contact a Criminal Defense Attorney to protect your rights. Do not think that a failure of the officers to advise you of your Miranda Rights is a guarantee to keep out incriminating statements by a motion to suppress. Very rarely will you "talk your way out of a situation". If officers are asking you questions about a crime, you should simply refuse to answer and contact an attorney.

Attorney Frank Walker of Frank Walker Law is a National Top 100 Criminal Defense Lawyer and Personal Injury Attorney with offices in Pittsburgh Pennsylvania and Morgantown West Virginia.

If you or someone you love are facing criminal charges or seriously injured in an accident, contact Attorney Frank Walker immediately at 412-315-7441, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week for aggressive and experienced Criminal Defense or Representation in a Civil Case.

Categories: Criminal Defense, Criminal Defense News, DUI, Fake ID, Homicide, Miranda Warnings, Motion to Suppress, Narcotics, Police Interviews, Preliminary Hearing, Public Intoxication, Retail theft, Theft Offenses

Share Post

Recent Posts

  • Attorney Donates Touch Free Thermometers to Allegheny County Courthouse
  • THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF DISTINGUISHED COUNSEL
  • Frank Walker Law Sponsors 2020 MLK Hoops Tournament
  • We Wrote a Book for What to Do When Charged with a Crime in Western Pennsylvania.
  • Pittsburgh Attorney Donates to Greensburg Stage Right Arts Program
  • Omega Psi Phi Backpack Giveaway
  • Attorney Walker Donates 100 Backpacks to Bloomfield - Garfield Corporation
  • Pittsburgh Criminal Defense Attorney takes a HUGE Stand Against Violence

Criminal Defense

How Can We Help You?

  • Do I Need A Criminal Defense Attorney?
  • Not from Pittsburgh?
  • Appeals
  • Criminal Defense FAQ
  • Arrest Warrants
  • Bail Bond Hearings
  • Bench Warrants
  • Casino Crimes
  • Conspiracy
  • Drug Crimes
  • DUI
  • Expungements
  • Fake ID
  • Federal Crimes
  • Grading Offenses
  • Internet Crimes
  • Juvenile Crimes
  • Kidnapping
  • Perjury
  • Pittsburgh College University Students
  • Preliminary Hearings
  • Probation Violations
  • Property Crimes
  • Prostitution and Promoting Prostitution
  • Public Urination
  • Resisting Arrest
  • Sex Crimes
  • Stages of Criminal Court
  • Summary Offenses
  • Theft Crimes
  • Traffic Offenses
  • Underage Drinking
  • Violent Crimes
  • Weapons - Firearms
  • Washington County

Contact Us Today

Request your free, confidential case analysis.

Send
My
Info
  • Home
  • Site Map
  • Nav Map
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
Frank Walker Law

Call Today (412) 212-3878

Frank Walker Law - Pittsburgh Criminal Defense Lawyer
3000 Lewis Run Road, Clairton, PA 15025 View Map
Main (412) 212-3878
Local (412) 315-7441
Website: http://www.frankwalkerlaw.com/
© 2022 All Rights Reserved.
Internet Marketing Experts